What We Now Know: Wikileaks and the War in Afghanistan

What We Now Know: Wikileaks and the War in Afghanistan

The story of how Wikileaks became instrumental in the biggest leak in US military history reads like a political thriller, and the fallout is likely to continue for days as specialists pour over its details.

But as a first cut, how credible is the response by the US government?

In his first comments on the leak yesterday, President Barack Obama claimed that the documents revealed nothing that hadn’t ‘already informed our public debate on Afghanistan’.

Whilst this was a clear attempt to downplay the impact of the story, the point stands up to some scrutiny.

Informed public debate?

Task Force 373

One of the more sensational headlines has been the activities of Task-Force 373, the so-called ‘kill or capture’ squads that have been hunting insurgent leaders in Afghanistan.

Although the details have been sketchy, the knowledge that this group exists has been in the public domain for some time.  As early as January 2008, wired.com’s Danger Room, which has had its own bit part in the leak story, reported on Task Force ODIN in Iraq, a story originally published in Defense News.

This equally shadowy outfit was designed to ‘Observe Detect Interdict and Neutralise’ bomb makers in what was, at the time, an insurgent-ridden Iraq.

But the report goes on to say, ‘success has led Army officials to expand it and to bring its tactics to Afghanistan’.  Indeed, its success was touted by none other than General David Patraeus, who recently took over command in Afghanistan from General Stanley McChrystal.

The fact that such Special Forces activities have operated separate from ISAF command was a point alluded to in Stephen Grey’s Operation Snakebite.  Part of the McChrystal strategy corrected this.

IED Casualties

The true extent of IED casualties among troops and the population at large is shocking certainly, but not data which couldn’t otherwise be gathered by a committed researcher.

The pattern of increasing IED incidents which was revealed by the leak also reflects more recent security reports which have documented the Taliban’s increasing reliance on this tactic, as well as the increasing sophistication of their design.

A report by the New America Foundation in April of this year, also in the public domain, concluded exactly this.  In addition the report noticed a growing trend elsewhere in the region including Pakistan and the separatist region of Balochistan.

The Role of Pakistan and Iran

The suggestion that Pakistani and Iranian elements have links to insurgents operating will come as a surprise to no one.

Even the most casual observer of Afghan affairs will be aware that the regional picture is complicated by the role of proxies operating with the help of certain regional states.  In a recent London School of Economics report the ‘double game’ of the Pakistani ISI was suggested to have reached a level at which ISI agents were attending meetings of the Quetta Shura Taliban, one of the main insurgent groups making up what is collectively known as the ‘Taliban’.

More recently, ISAF openly reported the killing by US and Afghan Special Forces, of Mullah Akhtar, an insurgent with known links to Iran. It was reported by ISAF that Akhtar ‘was responsible for arranging training for foreign fighters from Iran and helped resolve disputes between militant networks’.  On top of this, Gen McChrystal announced as recently as May this year that Afghan insurgents were training inside Iran.

Whilst such revelations can and have caused diplomatic embarrassment, they are generally denied.  However, the fact that states engage in such proxy warfare is hardly new, and is not likely to change.

The Killing of Civilians

The killing of innocent civilians by coalition forces is potentially the more damaging aspect of these leaks and will certainly do damage to the image of the ISAF operation as a whole.

We now have a better picture of the true extent of these incidents between 2004-09, but should we be surprised that such incidents have occurred?

President Hamid Karzai has repeatedly pleaded with NATO to reduce its reliance on airpower and change its standard operating procedures to guard against such events occurring – a message that finally got through with McChrystal’s new ‘population-centric strategy’ which took hold late last year.

The troubling aspect is the apparent covering-up of such incidents.  Yet again however, this is hardly surprising.  NATO is acutely aware of the damage that such incidents do to progress on the ground.  This point was illustrated more forcefully in a recent report which found that found a reduction in the use of force by NATO troops showed a significant correlation with a reduction in attacks on those troops.

The interpretation?  Less use of force on civilians = fewer insurgents.

A simple counter-insurgency argument that remains fiendishly difficult to achieve.

The Taliban Possessing Anti-Aircraft Weaponry

Finally, the revelation that the Taliban may have acquired an anti-aircraft capacity far earlier than we thought is alarming, but so far instances of aircraft being shot down in Afghanistan remains remarkably low.

In fact, one of the many questions that this leak raises, includes why haven’t more surface to air attacks taken place?  For all the external support the Taliban allegedly receives, we might equally ask, why won’t their supporters give them the weapon which helped defeat the Soviets only two decades ago?

Winners and Losers

As David Loyn of the BBC suggested in the immediate aftermath of the Wikileaks publication, the documents will be of most benefit to historians, who may now go ahead and write their books (should they be lucky enough to be publishing on the period 2004-09).

Aside from this, it is difficult to see who, if anyone, benefits from their publication.

The US and its allies must now contend with a more clued up public.  Much of the ‘public debate’ that Obama referred to has been lacking strong empirical evidence.  These leaks have provided flesh to the bones of the narratives supporting these debates.  Whilst the retort is that many of the problems these leaks highlight have been addressed, the contradictions inherent in the previous strategy are painfully laid bare by having all the data in one place, and the key question is now ‘is it all too little too late?’

Other losers include regional actors such as Iran and Pakistan who are once more fingered as spoilers in a war which continues to provoke instability within their own borders.   Finally, the Taliban must acknowledge that their methods and modes of operation are being closely watched, if not adequately countered.

As a footnote, their own targeting of civilians, which has if anything increased since NATO reduced its reliance on firepower, now looks even less flattering to its public relations image as a national liberation force.

T.E. Lawrence, or ‘Lawrence of Arabia’ as he is more popularly known, was a master of the irregular form of warfare we see in Afghanistan today.  In his opinion, waging war on rebellion was ‘messy and slow’.  There is little here which do anything to dispel this reality.  These documents paint a picture that Lawrence would surely recognize.  As General Sir David Richards more recently commented on Afghanistan, this is ‘persistent, low-level, dirty fighting’.

Those who expected a ‘Revolution in Military Affairs’ to take us away from this most troubling form of conflict will be disappointed.

Those who know their history will not be surprised.


In This Story: Afghanistan

Afghanistan, officially the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan, is a landlocked country at the crossroads of Central and South Asia. Afghanistan is bordered by Pakistan to the east and south; Iran to the west; Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, and Tajikistan to the north; and China to the northeast.

Occupying 652,000 square kilometers (252,000 sq mi), it is a mountainous country with plains in the north and southwest. Kabul is the capital and largest city. The population is around 32 million, composed mostly of ethnic Pashtuns, Tajiks, Hazaras, and Uzbeks.

3 Recent Items: Afghanistan

No women to attend major Taliban meeting in Afghanistan – BBC News

BREAKING: Taliban says ‘shots fired’ outside Grand Council meeting in Kabul

Afghanistan Earthquake Survivors Wait for International Aid

In This Story: Barack Obama

Barack Obama is an American politician and attorney who served as the 44th president of the United States from 2009 to 2017. A member of the Democratic Party, Obama was the first African-American president of the United States. He previously served as a U.S. senator from Illinois from 2005 to 2008 and an Illinois state senator from 1997 to 2004.

Obama left office in January 2017 and continues to reside in Washington, D.C.

Books #Ad

3 Recent Items: Barack Obama

Two experts debate the Biden administration’s energy policy amid high prices

Hillary Clinton, Stephen Hadley Discuss Legacy Of Madeleine Albright

LIVE: Hillary Clinton Discusses Global Diplomacy At Aspen Ideas Festival | NBC News

In This Story: Iran

Iran, also called Persia, officially the Islamic Republic of Iran, is a country in Western Asia. Its central location in Eurasia and proximity to the Strait of Hormuz give it significant geostrategic importance. Tehran is the capital and largest city.

Iran is home to one of the world’s oldest civilizations, beginning with the formation of the Elamite kingdoms in the fourth millennium BC. The Iranian Revolution established the current Islamic Republic in 1979.

Iran’s political system combines elements of a presidential democracy and an Islamic theocracy. Iran is a founding member of the UN, ECO, OIC, and OPEC. It is a major regional and middle power and has large reserves of fossil fuels — including the world’s largest natural gas supply and the third largest proven oil reserves.

The country’s rich cultural legacy is reflected in part by its 22 UNESCO World Heritage Sites. Historically a multi-ethnic country, Iran remains a pluralistic society comprising numerous ethnic, linguistic, and religious groups, the largest being Persians, Azeris, Kurds, Mazandaranis and Lurs.

4 Recent Items: Iran

New railway track connects China’s Ningxia with Middle East

Iran conducts second satellite carrier test launch ahead of nuclear talks

Nuclear talks between US and Iran to resume ‘in coming days’, Tehran and EU say • FRANCE 24 English

Tense moment Iranian speedboat nearly crashes into US warship

In This Story: Iraq

Iraq, officially the Republic of Iraq, is a country in Western Asia. The capital and largest city is Baghdad. Iraq is home to diverse ethnic groups including Arabs, Kurds, Turkmen, Assyrians, Yazidis, Shabakis, Armenians, Mandaeans, Circassians, Sabians and Kawliya. Around 99% of the country’s 38 million citizens are Muslims, with small minorities of Christians, Yarsans, Yezidis and Mandeans also present. The official languages of Iraq are Arabic and Kurdish.

Iraq has a coastline measuring 58 km (36 miles) on the northern Persian Gulf and encompasses the Mesopotamian Alluvial Plain, the northwestern end of the Zagros mountain range and the eastern part of the Syrian Desert. Two major rivers, the Tigris and Euphrates, run south through Iraq and into the Shatt al-Arab near the Persian Gulf. These rivers provide Iraq with significant amounts of fertile land. The region between the Tigris and Euphrates rivers, historically known as Mesopotamia, is often referred to as the cradle of civilisation.

Iraq is a federal parliamentary republic consisting of 19 governorates, four of which make up the autonomous Kurdistan Region. Disputes over the sovereignty of Kurdistan Region continue.

Iraq is a founding member of the UN as well as of the Arab League, OIC, Non-Aligned Movement and the IMF.

2 Recent Items: Iraq

Paris attacks trial: Who are the defendants? • FRANCE 24 English

Northern Iraq province declares state of emergency over cholera

In This Story: Pakistan

Pakistan, officially the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, is a country in South Asia. It has a population exceeding 212.2 million, including the world’s second-largest Muslim population. It has an area of 881,913 square kilometres (340,509 square miles).

Pakistan has a 1,046-kilometre (650-mile) coastline along the Arabian Sea and Gulf of Oman in the south and is bordered by India to the east, Afghanistan to the west, Iran to the southwest, and China to the northeast. It is separated narrowly from Tajikistan by Afghanistan’s Wakhan Corridor in the northwest, and also shares a maritime border with Oman.

3 Recent Items: Pakistan

Eoin Morgan’s maiden Test century vs Pakistan in 2010! 💯🙌

China-funded international airport in Pakistan expected to be ready in September 2023

Afghanistan: Taliban Deputy Minister weeps over the fallout of the earthquake

In This Story: Taliban

The Taliban or Taleban, who refer to themselves as the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan, is a Deobandi Islamist movement and military organization in Afghanistan, currently waging war within the country. Since 2016, the Taliban’s leader has been Mawlawi Hibatullah Akhundzada.

3 Recent Items: Taliban

No women to attend major Taliban meeting in Afghanistan – BBC News

BREAKING: Taliban says ‘shots fired’ outside Grand Council meeting in Kabul

Afghanistan Earthquake Survivors Wait for International Aid

In This Story: United States

The United States is a country also known as the United States of America, USA, US or just America. There are fifty states in the union, which is a federal republic ruled by a representative democracy. Nearly ten million square kilometres are inhabited by over 300 million people. The majority of Americans speak English.

4 Recent Items: United States

REPLAY – Biden: NATO more united after Russian invasion of Ukraine • FRANCE 24 English

President Biden holds news conference at NATO Summit in Madrid — 6/30/2022

NATO boosts forces in Europe to counter “direct threat” from Russia – BBC News

Is the world becoming less chaotic? | The Bottom Line

Leave a Comment

We don't require your email address, or your name, for anyone to leave a comment. If you do add an email address, you may be notified if there are replies to your comment - we won't use it for any other purpose. Please make respectful comments, which add value, and avoid personal attacks on others. Links are not allowed in comments - 99% of spam comments, attempt to post links. Please describe where people may find additional information - for example "visit the UN website" or "search Google for..." rather than posting a link. Comments failing to adhere to these guidelines will not be published.

Posting....