The Killing of Ahmed Wali Karzai and NATO’s Afghanistan Strategy

The gunning down of Ahmed Wali Karzai by his long-term head of security and confidant, Sardar Muhammed, is a significant blow to Afghanistan’s political stability in the South and exposes the fragility of NATO’s wider Afghanistan strategy.

Kandahar is often referred to as the ‘spiritual home’ of the Taliban movement. A status derived from the fact that it was the first significant city to come under Taliban control as the movement rolled out across the south in 1994. Indeed, Mullah Omar, the Taliban’s leader, preferred to govern Afghanistan from Kandahar rather than Kabul when the Taliban took power in 1996.

Aware of this, NATO has prioritized Kandahar as a strategic prize not only due to its role as a conduit for fighters from the south, but also as a result of its symbolic status for the Taliban movement.

Under the ‘surge strategy’ outlined by General McChrystal, Kandahar was given priority status, with the aim of seizing the province, breaking the Taliban’s momentum in the south, and bolstering the legitimacy of the national government through establishing firm control. NATO is equally aware that as ‘transition’ to Afghan control of security begins to become the dominant narrative in the Afghanistan strategy, key cities such as Kandahar must be under government control.

The power vacuum that will be left by the killing of Ahmed Wali Karzai will threaten this.

Karzai was not a governor of Kandahar, but as head of the Provincial Council he was a key political figure and power broker. He became in effect President Karzai’s representative in Kandahar and despite serious allegations over his links with narcotraffickers and other criminal elements (including the Taliban themselves), it was widely perceived that NATO had reached a modus Vivendi with him.

His strength derived from his relationship with the President, his status as a tribal leader within the province, and his ability to disburse patronage to local actors in return for their political acquiescence.

It is this more informal role that Ahmed Wali Karzai fulfilled which will be hardest to replace and exposes the frailties of NATO’s strategy.

Counter-insurgency is an inherently political process, its success is generally determined by the ability of the government to establish its authority in contested areas.

This has required NATO to work with the political grain of Afghanistan. It cannot, nor should not dictate its preference in terms political leadership, unless it wishes to immediately undermine the authority of those it proposes.

In the south, this leaves NATO at the mercy of what Britain’s former Ambassador to Afghanistan, Sir Sherard Cowper-Coles refers to as the ‘roiling sea’ of regional politics. Local leaders are not simply under threat from the Taliban, but from a multitude of interest groups. The cross cutting grievances such groups hold come from an array of local and regional pressures.

Narcotics, certainly have a part to play, but disenfrancisement over historically-rooted land disputes; political patronage; and indeed aid disbursement originating from the international presence itself also provoke rivalries.

Indeed, those closest to Ahmed Wali Karzai’s assassin expressed a profound skepticism over the Taliban’s claims that they had turned him. This state of affairs, resembling at times more of a civil war than an insurgency, is something that the Taliban continue to exploit.

In This Story: Afghanistan

Afghanistan, officially the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan, is a landlocked country at the crossroads of Central and South Asia. Afghanistan is bordered by Pakistan to the east and south; Iran to the west; Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, and Tajikistan to the north; and China to the northeast.

Occupying 652,000 square kilometers (252,000 sq mi), it is a mountainous country with plains in the north and southwest. Kabul is the capital and largest city. The population is around 32 million, composed mostly of ethnic Pashtuns, Tajiks, Hazaras, and Uzbeks.

3 Recent Items: Afghanistan

Suriname, Road Safety, Pooled Funds & other topics – Daily Press Briefing (30 June 2022)

No women to attend major Taliban meeting in Afghanistan – BBC News

BREAKING: Taliban says ‘shots fired’ outside Grand Council meeting in Kabul

In This Story: Taliban

The Taliban or Taleban, who refer to themselves as the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan, is a Deobandi Islamist movement and military organization in Afghanistan, currently waging war within the country. Since 2016, the Taliban’s leader has been Mawlawi Hibatullah Akhundzada.

3 Recent Items: Taliban

No women to attend major Taliban meeting in Afghanistan – BBC News

BREAKING: Taliban says ‘shots fired’ outside Grand Council meeting in Kabul

Afghanistan Earthquake Survivors Wait for International Aid

Leave a Comment

We don't require your email address, or your name, for anyone to leave a comment. If you do add an email address, you may be notified if there are replies to your comment - we won't use it for any other purpose. Please make respectful comments, which add value, and avoid personal attacks on others. Links are not allowed in comments - 99% of spam comments, attempt to post links. Please describe where people may find additional information - for example "visit the UN website" or "search Google for..." rather than posting a link. Comments failing to adhere to these guidelines will not be published.