UK Supreme Court: Farstad Supply AS (Appellant) v Enviroco Limited and another (Respondent) (Scotland)

Enviroco is not entitled to a contribution from Asco.

Farstad Supply AS (‘Farstad’) owned an oil rig supply vessel which was damaged by fire while berthed in harbour on 7 July 2002. At the time of the fire, the third party charterer, Asco UK Limited (‘Asco’), had engaged the defender, Enviroco Limited (‘Enviroco’), to clean out tanks on board the vessel. Following the fire, Farstad sued Enviroco for damages, alleging that the fire was caused by the negligence of Enviroco’s employees.

Enviroco, as well as alleging contributory negligence against Farstad’s employees, sought a contribution from Asco under section 3(2) of the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) (Scotland) Act 1940 (‘the 1940 Act’).

Section 3 of the 1940 Act is entitled “Contribution among joint wrongdoers”. Section 3(1) deals with the case where the party suing (Farstad) proceeds against two defenders in respect of loss or damage caused by both and a judgment is given against both, so that both are “found jointly and severally liable in damages”. Subsection (2) provides that a defender who has been held liable and pays damages to the suing party under subsection (1), has a right to recover such contribution as the court deems just from “any other person who, if sued, might also have been held liable in respect of the loss or damage on which the action was founded”.

By clause 33(5) of the charterparty, Farstad agreed to “defend, indemnify and hold harmless” Asco from all liabilities resulting from damage to the vessel. If therefore Enviroco was entitled to a contribution from Asco under section 3(2) it was agreed that Asco would (at the least) be entitled to an indemnity from Farstad under clause 33(5). Whatever the result therefore, Asco would not ultimately be liable.

The Supreme Court unanimously allows the appeal. The Court holds that Enviroco is not entitled to a contribution from Asco under section 3(2) of the 1940 Act because it cannot establish that “if sued” Asco might have been liable to Farstad in respect of losses caused by the fire. Lord Clarke delivered the leading judgment.

In his judgment, Lord Rodger confirmed that the Court’s construction of section 3(2) is in line with the established case law of the courts of New Zealand and Canada on similar provisions. The policy which underlies the decisions of those courts is equally applicable to Scots law.

The appeal is allowed and the decision of the Lord Ordinary is restored.

Resources

Full judgement: http://www.supremecourt.gov.uk/docs/UKSC_2009_0008_Judgment.pdf


In This Story: Canada

Canada is a country in the northern part of North America. It extends from the Atlantic to the Pacific and northward into the Arctic Ocean, covering 9.98 million square kilometres (3.85 million square miles), making it the world’s second-largest country by total area.

Its southern and western border with the United States, stretching 8,891 kilometres (5,525 mi), is the world’s longest bi-national land border. Canada’s capital is Ottawa, and its three largest metropolitan areas are Toronto, Montreal, and Vancouver.

Various Indigenous peoples inhabited what is now Canada for thousands of years before European colonization. The Canada Act 1982, which severed the vestiges of legal dependence on the British Parliament. Canada is a parliamentary democracy and a constitutional monarchy in the Westminster tradition, with a monarch and a prime minister who serves as the chair of the Cabinet and head of government.

As a highly developed country, Canada has the seventeenth-highest nominal per-capita income globally as well as the thirteenth-highest ranking in the Human Development Index. Its advanced economy is the tenth-largest in the world, relying chiefly upon its abundant natural resources and well-developed international trade networks.

2 Recent Items: Canada

Impact inflation, living costs have on birth rates and canadians on parental leave 3

Impact inflation, living costs have on birth rates and Canadians on parental leave

Global National: Jan. 19, 2024 | Health data shows influenza, COVID-19 cases decreasing in Canada

In This Story: New Zealand

New Zealand is an island country in the southwestern Pacific Ocean. It consists of two main landmasses—the North Island and the South Island —and around 600 smaller islands, covering a total area of 268,021 square kilometres.

4 Recent Items: New Zealand

We Talk: New Zealanders say Japan should consider other countries’ interests

Bloomberg Daybreak: Asia 01/19/2024

Bloomberg Daybreak: Australia 01/19/2024

Bloomberg Daybreak: Asia 01/18/2024

In This Story: UK Supreme Court

The Supreme Court is the final court of appeal in the United Kingdom for civil cases, and for criminal cases from England, Wales and Northern Ireland. It hears cases of the greatest public or constitutional importance affecting the whole population, including disputes relating to devolution.

2 Recent Items: UK Supreme Court

Watch live: The House of Commons debates the Rwanda Bill for the second day

Watch live: The House of Commons debates the Rwanda Bill

Leave a Comment

We don't require your email address, or your name, for anyone to leave a comment. If you do add an email address, you may be notified if there are replies to your comment - we won't use it for any other purpose. Please make respectful comments, which add value, and avoid personal attacks on others. Links are not allowed in comments - 99% of spam comments, attempt to post links. Please describe where people may find additional information - for example "visit the UN website" or "search Google for..." rather than posting a link. Comments failing to adhere to these guidelines will not be published.